I hear someone at NIF wrote a long paper on the state of ICF that
included bogus information, and it sparked a firestorm of criticism,
internal investigations, etc. Anyone know the story?
7 comments:
Anonymous
said...
I think this is the paper: http://www.psfc.mit.edu/icf/Home%20Page/Papers/Lindl_PoP-2014.pdf
Who could get through such a long paper? I just read the end about the high foot stuff. Doesn't seem out of the ordinary to me. Lindl is a pretty smart guy.
So the paper does exist. I would like to hear more on the reaction to the paper; who reacted, how they reacted, what level were they in the power structure.
7 comments:
I think this is the paper: http://www.psfc.mit.edu/icf/Home%20Page/Papers/Lindl_PoP-2014.pdf
Who could get through such a long paper? I just read the end about the high foot stuff. Doesn't seem out of the ordinary to me. Lindl is a pretty smart guy.
This thread started with "I hear..." and asked for details. Here they are:
you heard wrong
"Papergate", it's all over NIF.
That paper follows in the glorious tradition of LLNL and the deuterium EoS scandal.
So the paper does exist. I would like to hear more on the reaction to the paper; who reacted, how they reacted, what level were they in the power structure.
It is loaded with confirmation bias.
Post a Comment